'Appallingly hand-picked cronies': New leadership commission comes under fire

The pharmacy union and candidates for the Royal Pharmaceutical Society (RPS) national boards have warned that the new UK pharmacy professional leadership advisory board lacks “transparency” and risks “political interference”. 

leadership board
Running the board could take "up resources that could have sponsored other crucial services"

Earlier this week (April 23), the Pharmacists’ Defence Association (PDA) published views from prospective RPS national board members on “key issues” to inform voters.

Several of the candidates who volunteered their thoughts to the PDA raised concerns about the new UK pharmacy professional leadership advisory board, whose members were announced earlier this month (April 10) by the board’s chair and the UK’s four chief pharmaceutical officers (CPhOs) .

Read more: Podcast: Women in leadership roles and mental health

The board currently includes nine ex-officio members, an “independent chair” and nine “independent expert members” with the aim to “work collaboratively to….address together a wide range of professional issues”.

But when asked by the union about the board “installed by the four country CPhO’s”, RPS election candidate and pharmacist Martin Astbury said that in his opinion, the leadership advisory board “is not needed”.

“I believe that it appallingly consists of several hand-picked appointed cronies and in no way is representative or representing the profession,” he added.

“Taking up resources”

RPS board candidate and lead prescribing pharmacist and GP partner Shilpa Patel said that while she supported the board’s “commitment to addressing common issues” affecting the sector, she had concerns about “accountability”.

“Creating and maintaining such a board might mean taking up resources that could have sponsored other crucial services,” she said. 

“Accountability and political interference could threaten the board's efficiency and diminish the industry's confidence in it,” she added.

Read more: Just 14% believe pharmacy leadership ‘completely fit for purpose’

Meanwhile, RPS board candidate and PDA treasurer Alisdair Jones warned that the sector “must be mindful of any future attempt by politicians to take control of the profession”.

“We must remain in control of our professional destiny,” he said.

But Jones added that he supported “any endeavour that attempts to bring together” pharmacy organisations despite their “siloed nature”.

“Full transparency is a basic expectation”

It comes after the PDA last week (April 19) called for “greater transparency” around the board’s membership.

It said that “it should be for pharmacists to determine the leadership of their profession and not for employers of pharmacists nor governments”.

The union also raised concerns about the “expert board members” and called for each to publish “a full declaration of their interests”.

“Full transparency is a basic expectation for this kind of a body,” it stressed.

Read more: Former GPhC chair heads up commission on pharmacy professional leadership

A Scottish government spokesperson told C+D today (April 26) that the DH has established the leadership advisory board as “an independent public body” to ensure it “can carry out its remit effectively”.

“The board will set its own agendas and provide impartial advice to the existing professional leadership bodies and specialist professional groups”, they added.

"The UK CPhOs may also seek expert advice on professional leadership from the board, as well as from professional leadership bodies and specialist professional groups through existing arrangements,” they said. 

C+D also approached NHS England (NHSE), the Department of Health and Social Care (DH), the Welsh government, the Northern Irish government, the leadership board’s chair Sir Hugh Taylor KCB and all nine independent expert board members for comment.

Sign in or register for free

Kate Bowie

Read more by Kate Bowie

Kate Bowie joined C+D as a digital reporter in August 2023 after graduating from a master’s in journalism at City, University of London. She began covering the primary care beat at the end of 2022, when she carried out several health investigations focused on staffing issues, NHS funding and health inequalities.

Latest from News

Retired pharmacist crushed to death in canal boat accident

 
• By 
 • comment

Margaret Billings sustained fatal injuries when she was caught between a moving boat and a riverbank during a day out “with family and friends”, an inquest has found.

NHSE scrapped: ‘Fresh start or just more political chaos?’

 
• By 
 • comment

C+D rounds up some of the immediate pharmacy reaction to news that NHS England will be abolished, with more control moving back to the government and local leaders…

New primary care medical director role as 2-year NHSE axing begins

 
• By 
 • comment

Wes Streeting has revealed that the DH is “immediately” working to scrap NHS England (NHSE) and put a new “transformation team” in place – adding that it is in the “very final stages” of concluding a new pharmacy contract deal.

More from Business

breaking news

IN FULL: Boots’ parent company sold in $24bn private equity deal

 
• By 
 • comment

Walgreens Boots Alliance (WBA) has “entered into a definitive agreement to be acquired” by private equity firm Sycamore Partners.

Jhoots accounts: Shareholder funds tumble while debts soar

 
• By 
 • comment

Jhoots Chemist’s accounts for 2024 have revealed an almost £2 million year-on-year dip in shareholder funds – as debts to creditors increase more than £2m.